Skip to main content

Table 2 Results of voting on ‘selecting 10 criteria considered to be particularly important’

From: Enhancing evidence-informed policymaking in medicine and healthcare: stakeholder involvement in the Commons Project for rare diseases in Japan

Candidates of criteria for priority setting

Total (21)

Patients and family members (12)

Researchers (7)

Former policymakers (2)

Research topics related to various QOL aspects such as psychological and lifestyle aspects

18

11

5

2

Research topics related to life and death

17

9

6

2

Research topics related to expected findings meant to alleviate patients’ pain and burden and lead them to gain ‘independence’

16

11

4

1

Research topics that cannot be solved without involving researchers or policymakers

13

9

4

0

Research topics that patients readily experience as issues and would directly feel the benefits of, if properly addressed

13

7

5

1

Research topics related to physical function

11

6

3

2

Research topics that directly affect the diseases or the patients themselves

11

8

3

0

Research topics that impact society as a whole (social systems or individuals’ behaviours)

11

4

6

1

Research topics on the difficulties that cause other problems, and their resolution which is expected to simultaneously solve many other problems

10

4

5

1

Research topics related to children

9

6

2

1

Research topics related to many rare diseases

8

4

3

1

Research topics specific to rare diseases

8

4

3

1

Research topics whose findings could have a ripple effect beyond rare intractable diseases

8

4

2

2

Research topics that have big disadvantages before and big advantages after finding a solution

8

5

2

1

Research topics related to expected research findings that lead to reducing the burden imposed on families and healthcare providers

8

6

1

1

Topics of research in which resources and knowledge are already available, and their application remains a bottleneck

8

5

3

0

Research topics with few studies addressing the issue

8

4

4

0

Research topics where Internet use is expected to be an effective problem-solving tool

7

4

2

1

Research topics that affect the surrounding environment, such as families and healthcare providers

6

5

1

0

Research topics expected to have a high cost-effectiveness

5

1

2

2

Research topics on problems that cannot be resolved even though patients have been making their own efforts

5

4

1

0

Topics of research that can be carried out with limited time and resources

4

1

3

0

Topics on which research has been set aside or delayed because the number of the patients with the rare disease is so small, or the diseases were not life-threatening

N/A

N/A

N/A

N/A

Research topics that require legal knowledge and that aim to bridge gaps between real life and related laws

N/A

N/A

N/A

N/A

Research topics that aim to develop new applications and methods for newly discovered or invented technologies (e.g. iPS cells)

N/A

N/A

N/A

N/A